Bendix replacement Question - 1935 Ford

[Forgotten Ford]

Hello folks!
I have broken the bendix starter gear and sleeve (original one)

2 things broken: Bendix Starter Drive Shaft Sleeve and the Main gear (10 tooths).

Question: I'm thinking to ordering from Mac's a USA Bendix Style to replace, but I saw that have a modern style one that fit to the 59AB engine.

Have somebody used this new style? Is it better than the original style one?

tks Rod