Only cut what has to come out for rot ; usually 2-3”. As seems like you stated, DO NOT replace a full panel!
Email be direct and I will give you some interesting info about such. I make my own and will send you pics.
[email protected]
To answer your question….no one makes a “really good one” and last I heard they were out of stock but see them on eBay (Snyder’s shows them out of stock)