Sponsored Links (Register now to hide all advertisements)
I've used Magic Wadding Polish but go easy with it. Don't get aggressive and rub hard take it slow.
Also wipe in straight lines from the bottom out to the edge, don't wipe in a circle following around the reflector.
Best thing to do is probably either have them re-silvered, like you are going to do, or buy Bratton's reflectors. Strange as it sounds I kind of like the look of them yellowed a little looks more authentic and antique.