The Ford Barn

The Ford Barn (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/index.php)
-   Model A (1928-31) (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   convert to LED headlights (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/showthread.php?t=286322)

James G. 08-28-2020 03:28 PM

convert to LED headlights
 

I do a bit of night time driving when on solo touring. For safety I want to convert my original incondecent to LED "bulbs". The word is they are a significant improvement thus safer on the road. What all is involved for this change. I do not want to make modifications to any original features/parts thus, hopefully just a plug in will get the job done. Even so, will the LED system retain the focusing ability to optimize the road illumination for night time driving?
Pix please would be a great help if more than bulb replacement is required. Also, which and where is the best place for the needed quality parts.
Many thanks.

Kurt in NJ 08-28-2020 03:40 PM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

Due to design constraints it will be impossible to get proper focus with existing led systems in original reflector---- you will get a lot of bright light all around like a flood light, but you want a beam projected down the road like a spot light to see in the distance

McMimmcs 08-28-2020 03:53 PM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kurt in NJ (Post 1925116)
Due to design constraints it will be impossible to get proper focus with existing led systems in original reflector---- you will get a lot of bright light all around like a flood light, but you want a beam projected down the road like a spot light to see in the distance

I agree! I converted and my garage is brighter but down the road is no better and possibly worse than before conversion.

BRENT in 10-uh-C 08-28-2020 04:37 PM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kurt in NJ (Post 1925116)
Due to design constraints it will be impossible to get proper focus with existing led systems in original reflector---- you will get a lot of bright light all around like a flood light, but you want a beam projected down the road like a spot light to see in the distance

Kurt, you are talking two different things. I can tell you from first-hand experience that there is no need to focus. With one incandescent filament, there is a need to position (focus) the single filament wire in the parabolic shape of the reflector to project the light beam as far as possible. In an LED bulb, there are multiple light sources emitting light at a much higher intensity than the incandescent bulb. Therefore you get more lumen output with the LED over the incandescent bulb, you get a further beam travel with the LED bulb, and you have less electrical draw with the LED.

I will tell you straight-up that I had 50-50 candlepower bulbs mounted in Bratton's reflectors, and focused just like in the Service Bulletins. A year or so ago I switched over to the good quality LED direct replacement bulbs, and I have more light in front of the vehicle, I can see further down the road, and my generator has no trouble keeping up. I did re-aim my headlights downward just a tad, not because I was blinding people, but because I wanted a heavier concentration of light to see 25-50 foot in front of the bumper. And, ....to your point, Yes I have lost my ability to focus the LED bulb however I have no reason to want to focus this bulb. Its kinda like saying if you put one of those toolboxes in front of the radiator, you won't be able to hand crank start the engine. My attitude is ... 'So!' simply because I don't need to hand crank my Model-A.

.
.

Dean Lemoine 08-28-2020 05:16 PM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

I recently installed Logolites LED “bulbs” in new reproduction headlights. Honestly I haven’t driven the car at night to see if they need adjusting or how bright they are. But, the low beams blink constantly while the high beam is fine. I was thinking it may be a wiring issue so I swapped the position of the LED on both lights. The low beam still blinks and the bright continues to be fine.
I e-mailed Logo today, no response yet.

Tom Endy 08-28-2020 05:59 PM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dean Lemoine (Post 1925148)
I recently installed Logolites LED “bulbs” in new reproduction headlights. Honestly I haven’t driven the car at night to see if they need adjusting or how bright they are. But, the low beams blink constantly while the high beam is fine. I was thinking it may be a wiring issue so I swapped the position of the LED on both lights. The low beam still blinks and the bright continues to be fine.
I e-mailed Logo today, no response yet.

I have the same problem with a set of Logo LED lights. One of the bulbs wants to blink on low beams. I switched them in the headlights and the blink went with it, so I am sure it is a defective LED.

I believe they are made in China. All of the suppliers are currently out of stock.

Tom Endy

Dean Lemoine 08-28-2020 06:03 PM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

Tom, According to the website the LEDs are currently not in production due to Covid issues.

old31 08-28-2020 06:33 PM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

No one has those leds, I tried.

I switched from 50/50's to logo's and I am happy. Ya you use the focus ability but the pluses are much better as Brent mentioned.

Synchro909 08-28-2020 07:27 PM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

Every body looks at the conversion to LED lights from behind the steering wheel. Maybe, for the driver of that car, they are OK but by my experience, any oncoming driver is blinded by the dazzle no matter how well the driver thinks they are focused. A blinded driver coming straight at you at a closing speed of maybe 200 kph is not my idea of safety.

KGBnut 08-28-2020 07:54 PM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

Brent, whose LED bulbs are you using?

nomadpsd 08-28-2020 07:55 PM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

I got mine here. Same bulb as the LogoLights.

https://www.ledlight.com/led-headlig...polarized.aspx

PalAl 08-29-2020 08:42 AM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

Some RFA's Club members are using these and really like them. My understanding is they got them at a show, not sure how it would be dealing direct with the company. I don't believe this company has any US distributors. First link is home page, second is direct to Model A LED Headlight

http://www.classicandvintagebulbs.com/

http://www.classicandvintagebulbs.com/page6.html

Jack Shaft 08-29-2020 08:56 AM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

With a 12v conversion I used halogen H4 reflectors and installed the H4 based high/low LED bulbs...8k lumens.Nice white light,very bright.I aimed the buckets,dont blind oncoming drivers.Completely different bulbs than the 'A' ones,they have a mini fan in them..

https://i.imgur.com/7vW6P5X.jpg?1

https://i.imgur.com/K1jyOp1.jpg?1

Conaway2 08-29-2020 09:05 AM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

I converted headlights on my car - with stock electrical system - to the LogoLites LEDs last fall and have been very happy with them. My experience with them is much like Brent’s in post #4 - lots more light in front of the car at night, and current draw is about 2 amps.

Check Smith and Jones Model A parts in Columbia, SC - they may still have some.

Jim

GPierce 08-29-2020 09:26 AM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by BRENT in 10-uh-C (Post 1925139)
Kurt, you are talking two different things. I can tell you from first-hand experience that there is no need to focus. With one incandescent filament, there is a need to position (focus) the single filament wire in the parabolic shape of the reflector to project the light beam as far as possible. In an LED bulb, there are multiple light sources emitting light at a much higher intensity than the incandescent bulb. Therefore you get more lumen output with the LED over the incandescent bulb, you get a further beam travel with the LED bulb, and you have less electrical draw with the LED.

I will tell you straight-up that I had 50-50 candlepower bulbs mounted in Bratton's reflectors, and focused just like in the Service Bulletins. A year or so ago I switched over to the good quality LED direct replacement bulbs, and I have more light in front of the vehicle, I can see further down the road, and my generator has no trouble keeping up. I did re-aim my headlights downward just a tad, not because I was blinding people, but because I wanted a heavier concentration of light to see 25-50 foot in front of the bumper. And, ....to your point, Yes I have lost my ability to focus the LED bulb however I have no reason to want to focus this bulb. Its kinda like saying if you put one of those toolboxes in front of the radiator, you won't be able to hand crank start the engine. My attitude is ... 'So!' simply because I don't need to hand crank my Model-A.

.
.


Thank you Brent. I have commented several times with the results you experienced. Every time the focus issue is brought up. The bottom line is I can see much better and am more comfortable driving at night.

Jack Shaft 08-29-2020 09:52 AM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

12.57 lumens for each candle power..so 50cp is roughly 625 lumens..my LED's put out 8000 lumens..focus the beam? nah,turn the night into day

BRENT in 10-uh-C 08-29-2020 10:48 AM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by KGBnut (Post 1925200)
Brent, whose LED bulbs are you using?

I am not really sure. I did not get them from a normal Model-A vendor. As I recall, someone here mentioned the direct replacement type from a vendor either in England or maybe Australia. Then someone mentioned they had a US distributor, and that is who I purchased them from. Again, this has probably been a couple years ago now.



Mine do not blink that I know of Tom. The only thing mine did was they weren't very bright the first time I turned them on. I was kinda disappointed at first and stepped away. When I came back a few minutes later, they were much brighter. I don't know if the blinking will be something similar, where it corrects itself over time??

BRENT in 10-uh-C 08-29-2020 10:51 AM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Synchro909 (Post 1925191)
Every body looks at the conversion to LED lights from behind the steering wheel. Maybe, for the driver of that car, they are OK but by my experience, any oncoming driver is blinded by the dazzle no matter how well the driver thinks they are focused. A blinded driver coming straight at you at a closing speed of maybe 200 kph is not my idea of safety.

Quite frankly, I have not experienced this. I have two sets of these in Model-T headlights where an adjustment is difficult at best since you must bend the headlight stand to adjust, and I don't see oncoming vehicles flash their lights at me. Maybe that is because we are driving on the correct side of the road! :p :D

Phil Brown 08-29-2020 11:09 AM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jack Shaft (Post 1925305)
With a 12v conversion I used halogen H4 reflectors and installed the H4 based high/low LED bulbs...8k lumens.Nice white light,very bright.I aimed the buckets,dont blind oncoming drivers.Completely different bulbs than the 'A' ones,they have a mini fan in them..

https://i.imgur.com/7vW6P5X.jpg?1

https://i.imgur.com/K1jyOp1.jpg?1

That's a LED light you show and the ones with a fan are typically LED's
I have a set in my modern truck and love them. the 31 truck has H4 Halogen and they work very well also.
I do wonder about how well the cooling fan works enclosed in the headlight bucket ?
One side note; a blinking of flashing LED IS an defective light :( Not a wiring problem
The car looks nice got any more pics, would love to see

Kevin in NJ 08-29-2020 12:19 PM

Re: convert to LED headlights
 

What is not brought out is where the light goes. It gets glossed over.

The point to focusing the lamp is to put the light where it needs to go and not into the trees or the eyes of the oncoming cars.

A while ago someone did tests with a light measuring device and found the halogen solution did put almost the same amount of light where you need it to drive. But it also put a lot of light all over the place.

Pretty sure blinding oncoming traffic or be in the mirror of the car in front is a good thing.

So a real test would be measuring the light in multiple places. I am pretty sure there are standards for light amounts in areas in front of the car.

Do these LED lamps meet these requirements when used in the A headlamps?

We do not know and likely will never know. If you are going to ask the questions you need to ask the right questions.

As I recall the original type bulb with a good reflector and properly focused did a decent job lighting the road. A direct fit halogen did better. Both work fine with factory electrics.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:08 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.