The Ford Barn

The Ford Barn (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/index.php)
-   Model A (1928-31) (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/showthread.php?t=288995)

dmaxweb 10-21-2020 11:29 AM

Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

Has anyone attempted to use the scroll window handles and the escutcheons sold by Brattons? The handles are too big for the hole in the escutcheon.

I called them and they told me they are aware of this. Furthermore, they're not sure which part is incorrect. All they could say is that based on the source of each part (handles-China, escutcheons-A&L) the diameter of the handle is likely the problem.

Seems to me the fitment would have been noted in the catalog. I sure wish I had known this before having the handles nickel plated.

BRENT in 10-uh-C 10-21-2020 11:42 AM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by dmaxweb (Post 1943766)

Seems to me the fitment would have been noted in the catalog. I sure wish I had known this before having the handles nickel plated.

I feel your pain. Customers do not realize that we pretty much need to assemble their vehicle twice during the restoration process. If you don't mock-fit everything, it will haunt you in the end. Assembling twice costs money too.

dmaxweb 10-21-2020 12:31 PM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

2 Attachment(s)
Wonder if you cross drill a piece of key stock for the pin and then shave down the handle barrel. The rest of the handle may be in the way.

I have a friend who is a retired tool and die maker with a nice shop. Time to pay him a visit.

Turning it down would require removing the chrome under the nickel exposing bare metal. The cost of having them nickel plated again is minimal.

The second picture shows the furthest the handle will go into the escutcheon.

J Franklin 10-21-2020 12:39 PM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

The area of the handle, if turned down and under the escutcheons would not be visible. Would you really need to replace them?

CarlG 10-21-2020 12:48 PM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

Is it the plating that made it too large to fit the escutcheon?

dmaxweb 10-21-2020 12:54 PM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

I would not replace the handles just have these replated. I was just anticipating the possibilty that visible areas of the handle may get scratched in this process and to a lesser degree rust of the bare metal. Besides, no more than $10 to have both butler plated again.

dmaxweb 10-21-2020 12:59 PM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by CarlG (Post 1943796)
Is it the plating that made it too large to fit the escutcheon?


No. Brattons confirmed that off their shelf they do not fit. The butler nickel is pretty much gossamer plating and this problem is way more than that.

alexiskai 10-21-2020 02:03 PM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

https://www.brattons.com/show-qualit...scutcheon.html

"Will only work with original handles. Current reproductions are too large to fit into this escutcheon."

No idea when they added that, though. Could've been yesterday. And apparently not in the print catalog.

dmaxweb 10-21-2020 03:36 PM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by alexiskai (Post 1943814)
https://www.brattons.com/show-qualit...scutcheon.html

"Will only work with original handles. Current reproductions are too large to fit into this escutcheon."

No idea when they added that, though. Could've been yesterday. And apparently not in the print catalog.

Interesting. I talked to them yesterday and I'm reasonably sure that was not there earlier. If it was, my aplogies. Well I'm glad they added it for others going forward. I realize that it's buyer beware when dealing with repro parts but I am a bit dissapointed on this one.

J Franklin 10-21-2020 06:39 PM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

If you are careful the handle parts that are visible won't get scratched or damaged. BTW who is doing the plating so reasonably?

dmaxweb 10-22-2020 05:01 AM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

Sometimes it helps to sleep on situations.

It occurred to me that rather than making the oversize China handle fit the correct size U.S. escutcheon, I will just get a pair of China escutcheons (which do fit the China handles) and butler plate them. The stamping is not as crisp as the U.S. ones but really not noticable.

Much simpler solution to the problem and a heads-up to any of you.

ryanheacox 10-22-2020 07:49 AM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

I will say, I had to replace a couple of my scroll window riser handles and the quality of the new ones is far, far superior to the old ones that broke on me. They were paper thin vintique repros. I'm frankly amazed they worked at all before they snapped.

dmaxweb 10-22-2020 08:05 AM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

2 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by ryanheacox (Post 1944043)
I will say, I had to replace a couple of my scroll window riser handles and the quality of the new ones is far, far superior to the old ones that broke on me. They were paper thin vintique repros. I'm frankly amazed they worked at all before they snapped.

I too am very happy with the current scroll handles especially when replated butler nickel. Of course the USA repro escutcheons are really nice. Unfortunately they don't play well together.

Oh well, lesson learned and moving on to the next hurdle whatever that might be.

dmaxweb 10-22-2020 07:32 PM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by ryanheacox (Post 1944043)
I will say, I had to replace a couple of my scroll window riser handles and the quality of the new ones is far, far superior to the old ones that broke on me. They were paper thin vintique repros. I'm frankly amazed they worked at all before they snapped.

Do your scroll window handles have the "ridge" down the back? I've had someone tell me that the originals did not have this. I can't tell by the drawing in the JS.

ryanheacox 10-23-2020 06:44 AM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

I can't speak for the originals but I don't think mine have that ridge. I've also never seen that before. I can check later today. I bought a couple repros a few years ago now so it was probably a different batch.

dmaxweb 10-23-2020 07:26 AM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

3 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by ryanheacox (Post 1944352)
I can't speak for the originals but I don't think mine have that ridge. I've also never seen that before. I can check later today. I bought a couple repros a few years ago now so it was probably a different batch.

Well these are from Bratton's. So now not only do the escutcheons not fit these handles, the handles themselves are wrong. This is quite frustrating! Pictures of the boxes the window handles came in attached.

Also attached here is a picture of the door latch handles I ordered at the same time. They have a soft raised area with a taper. They certainly don't match the window handles. Are they closer to original or am I going to be even more upset?

ryanheacox 10-23-2020 08:35 AM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

I'll have to take a good look at mine when I get home. Mine also might not be the one to base anything off of since they are probably a mismatched set of repro parts. I'm pretty sure the ones I got came from Snyders in 2015.

dmaxweb 10-23-2020 08:52 AM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

I just spoke with Snyders. They indicated their window handle does "not look exactly like the picture [on their website] and it does have the vein down the middle."

Disappointing about the part but kudos to them for being pleasant and helpful.

dmaxweb 10-23-2020 12:56 PM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

Does anyone have a picture(s) of an original scroll handle to post?
Thanks

Bick in New Zealand 10-25-2020 01:45 AM

Re: Window Riser Handles and "Show Quality" Nickel Plated Escutcheons
 

1 Attachment(s)
Here you go.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:42 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, vBulletin Solutions Inc.