starter not engaging
 

Went out to start my 30 today and the starter won't engage. It's spinning and sounds a little "rattley". I haven't taken it apart yet but for those of you who have worked on them a lot can you give a guess on what went wrong?

Re: starter no engaging
 

If the starter would spin but not engage , it could be something simple like oil on the starter drive .

Re: starter not engaging
 

More than likely it is a broken bendix spring, or perhaps a bolt holding the bendix spring is broken or has backed itself out. I had that happen to me once. A tab on the lock washer broke and the bolt backed out and fell into the bellhousing. I was able to fish it out with a tool I have that I think I got at Harbor Freight. It's a combination magnet, grappling claw and light on the end of stiff but flexible cable. I shoved it down through the starter hole (after removing the starter), below the flywheel, and sure enough the magnet got it and I fished the bolt out. This happened at a New England meet, and I did the repair in the parking lot. I carry a spare bendix drive, so I was able to replace the lock washer.

Re: starter not engaging
 

I don't understand how the bendix works on that starter. Can you explain it to me?

Re: starter not engaging
 

The bendix spring is held in place by two bolts with special lockwashers. They have a tendency to eventually break with all of the torque that happens on the drive gear each time the starter is engaged. If they are not installed correctly, they will fall out. That happened to me two months ago. They are tricky to get out, what I did was stick a magnet on the flywheel and rotate it. If you drop a magnet in there - no big deal, the flywheel ring gear will pulverize it with no damage since it is hardened (which is also what I did).

Re: starter not engaging
 

Just two weeks ago this happened to me . You exact symtoms. It was missimg one bolt on the bendix spring. Replaced new tab lock washer and bolt . total repair time in and out about 1 1/2 hours. Glad it happened when it did. was going on a 100 mile trip the next day!!

Re: starter not engaging
 

Mine broke right in the garage. Not typical!

Re: starter not engaging
 

A weak battery can also be the cause---the gear is on a screw thread attached to the shaft with a cushion spring, that spring is attached with bolts with special locking washers

if the battery is weak it won't spin the starter to speed quick enough to screw the gear into mesh with the fly wheel ---ih there is congealed grease on the threads the gear will stick

as has been mentioned, the bolts can break or come out

another thing that can happen with wear the gear can hit the ring gear just wrong and jam, then you put car in 3rd gear and rock to jar it loose

Re: starter not engaging
 

Take your starter out and look at it.

Re: starter not engaging
 

I agree, Take it out and have a look.

Re: starter not engaging
 

Of course I will. I didn't have time yesterday though and just wanted to get some opinions.

Re: starter not engaging
 

Probably just a broken bendix spring. The classic failure. Easy to fix and does not cost much. If you are in a club, someone will have one in their tool box.

Re: starter not engaging
 

Yep broken spring. Fortunately nothing fell into the housing. Thanks for the input gentlemen!

Re: starter not engaging
 

I just noticed... Mine doesn't have that small pinion gear spring. Should I get a bendix that has that or isn't it necessary?

Re: starter not engaging
 

Post a picture. There are two basic types of bendix. barrell type and original(open). There is only one spring. With the curled ends.

Re: starter not engaging
 

Look at the original style bendix on Snyders or Mac's. There is a very light spring at the end opposite of the flat heavy spring.

Re: starter not engaging
 

That’s not a spring. It’s the spiral cut the bendix rides back and forth on.
In the picture, I can see how you might think it’s a spring,

Re: starter not engaging
 

There's a spring. I even called Mac's and they said there's a lightweight spring to push the gear back out of the flywheel. He said if I didn't have one it's missing.

Re: starter not engaging
 

not all have that spring/plunger, there are several different designs, to complicate the differences more I have used parts of Citroen drives in flatheads and A, and used "A" drive in Citroen
there is one version that has a weak spring on the shaft that pushes the gear directly, there is a version with the little spring/plungerthat rides in a smaller diameter area when retracted and a version without either.
the gear gets pushed back when the engine starts, the little springs/pins etc are only to keep the gear from vibrating into the ring gear

post some pictures of what you have

Re: starter not engaging
 

This is the spring he is asking about.