The Ford Barn

The Ford Barn (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/index.php)
-   Model A (1928-31) (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   converted to hydraulic, no brakes (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/showthread.php?t=298889)

TomIII 05-22-2021 04:28 PM

converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

5 Attachment(s)
had my '30 on stands for the winter...it's converted to hydraulic brakes...pedal went to the floor today... topped off the reservoir, still nothing... any ideas?

Model A Ron 05-22-2021 04:35 PM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

Do you still have your old parts for mechanical brakes? You may want to go back to mechanical.

Neshkoro 05-22-2021 04:51 PM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

Hydraulic brakes on a Model A is no different than any other car. If there was fluid and and you had brakes and now there's no fluid, you have a leak. Look for a puddle. If there's no puddle, it could be a defective master cylinder. The piston seal could be bad and its slipping past the fluid. Start with the master cylinder. Check for fluid. If it's low, add fluid and see if the pedal comes up. Then check for leaks at each wheel cylinder. Process of elimination. Maybe they just need to be bled to get the air out.

Jim in Wisconsin 05-22-2021 06:41 PM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

Henry Ford would smile and say "The safety of steel, from pedal to wheel".

Patrick L. 05-22-2021 06:55 PM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

Sounds like air, bleed the system.

McMimmcs 05-22-2021 07:28 PM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

Air or a leak. Check for a leak first.

mass A man 05-22-2021 10:11 PM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

As we don't know whom or how well the conversion to hydraulics went and you don't see or SMELL a puddle, check to see if the rod from pedal-to-master cyl. fell out or isn't engaging. Other than that, if it not a spongy pedal, but "all the way to the floor" sounds like a master cylinder failure.

700rpm 05-22-2021 10:13 PM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

Hydraulic brake coversions are not inherently or automatically an improvement over the mechanicals, and the OP further confirms this.

Model A Ron 05-22-2021 10:26 PM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jim in Wisconsin (Post 2019122)
Henry Ford would smile and say "The safety of steel, from pedal to wheel".

To each their own but I just do not see the need for juice brakes on a Model A. Its not hard to stop at all and I have locked the brakes up without much difficulty. Once your skidding what difference or advantage would hydraulic brakes give you?

steve hackel 05-22-2021 11:01 PM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

Whether or not someone converts their model A to hydraulics from mechanical, has nothing to do with the skid factor - but rather what size tires you are running and what size is the contact of the tire to the pavement. IF - AND I DID SAY IF you are running larger / wider tires with a larger footprint or contact pattern, then the original mechanical brakes will not provide enough force to lock the brakes. Stop comparing apples to oranges - stop comparing hydraulics to Fords ORIGINAL mechanicals , when you do not interject the size of the tires your running, or planning on running on your model A ! ��
This topic continually comes up and the
question(s) are neither fully asked, nor answered.
What size tires are you running - stock size tires and mechanical brakes are just fantastic.
Mechanical brakes and LARGE CONTACT foot print tires do not work, because if they did then Ford would have never bothered to go hydraulic.
Please, for God's sake, put this topic to rest.

Model A Ron 05-22-2021 11:19 PM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by steve hackel (Post 2019185)
Whether or not someone converts their model A to hydraulics from mechanical, has nothing to do with the skid factor - but rather what size tires you are running and what size is the contact of the tire to the pavement. IF - AND I DID SAY IF you are running larger / wider tires with a larger footprint or contact pattern, then the original mechanical brakes will not provide enough force to lock the brakes. Stop comparing apples to oranges - stop comparing hydraulics to Fords ORIGINAL mechanicals , when you do not interject the size of the tires your running, or planning on running on your model A ! ��
This topic continually comes up and the
question(s) are neither fully asked, nor answered.
What size tires are you running - stock size tires and mechanical brakes are just fantastic.
Mechanical brakes and LARGE CONTACT foot print tires do not work, because if they did then Ford would have never bothered to go hydraulic.
Please, for God's sake, put this topic to rest.

Once your skidding what difference or advantage would hydraulic brakes give you with stock wheels?......the answer is no advantage with stock wheels. Thank you

Bob Johnson 05-23-2021 12:16 AM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

Mechanical advantage is mechanical advantage. The pressure on the brake shoes is dependent on the pressure on the brake pedal and the ratio of the pedal movement to the shoe movement. It does not matter if you are using metal rods and levers or fluid and pistons. However the size of the brake drums and shoes and the materials used for the drums and shoe linings will make a difference. Mechanical brakes can have a problem with worn out or improper parts. Hydraulic brake can have problems with leaks or worn out parts. If you believe that mechanical brakes are better use them. If you believe hydraulic brakes a better use them. But whatever you use make sure they are in top condition.



Bob

katy 05-23-2021 10:47 AM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by TomIII (Post 2019085)
had my '30 on stands for the winter...it's converted to hydraulic brakes...pedal went to the floor today... topped off the reservoir, still nothing... any ideas?

Will the brakes "pump up"?

Chris Haynes 05-23-2021 12:20 PM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

I love my hydraulic brakes. 1940-1948 Ford stuff. Installed properly with no modification to body or frame. My engine is well over 40 HP and travels at a good rate of speed. 750x16 tires on the rear. The brakes work well.
A trip for bleeding the brakes. Get a hand held oil can with a pump in it. Fill it with brake fluid. Start at thr back of your car. Fit a piece of hose on the tip of the oil can and slip it over the bleeder valve on your brakes. Pump in fluid until you friend sees it entering the master cylinder. tighten the valve and move to the next one . Do this with all four and you will have no air in the lines and no wasted fluid on the ground.

TomIII 05-23-2021 12:24 PM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

no... I'm used to having them "pump up", but not this time. Looking for a rebuild kit, but can't find ID for the master cyl.:-(

Patrick L. 05-23-2021 12:47 PM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

Well, you haven't mentioned much. Try bleeding them first. If you think there is a master issue then disconnect the line, make up one to return the fluid back into the reservoir and keep pumping the heck out of it until you're sure all the air is out. They can be a PITA to get the air out of. But if you really want to remove and rebuild it first, fine. It'll still have to be bled.

Charlie Stephens 05-23-2021 12:52 PM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by TomIII (Post 2019353)
no... I'm used to having them "pump up", but not this time. Looking for a rebuild kit, but can't find ID for the master cyl.:-(

Post a picture of the master cylinder. If you don't know how to post a picture PM me and I will do it for you while you are busy learning how to do it.

Charlie Stephens

1931 flamingo 05-23-2021 01:41 PM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

39-48 m/cyl is the same. Look for a leak first (IF M/Cyl was low). Get a NEW M/cyl. JMO
Let us know what you find.
Paul in CT

gdmn852 05-23-2021 06:51 PM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

From my experience I had this happen on cars that were in storage for the winter.If there are no brakes at all chances are a wheel cylinder is leaking or a bad hose ,fittings or even the steel lines .If you have been pumping brakes to get them to work something is leaking allowing air in the system.The brakes are something I find I use quite often. Let us know what you find .

Gene F 05-23-2021 07:43 PM

Re: converted to hydraulic, no brakes
 

Where on the car is this master cylinder located?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:28 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.