The Ford Barn

The Ford Barn (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/index.php)
-   Model A (1928-31) (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   Converting Model A to key starting (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/showthread.php?t=61209)

Dave in Denver 02-05-2012 09:41 PM

Converting Model A to key starting
 

I am thinking of converting my '31 closed cab truck with a Riley ohv banger engine from foot starting to key starting using a selonoid. The truck is wired for 12 volts today. I have heard of this but am not sure how to wire it up and what part I may need to make it work. Might any one be able provide me some advice or recommendations? Thanks.

BCCHOPIT 02-05-2012 10:09 PM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

I am thinking of doing the same thing.
I was going to use a 37-48 starter solenoid and
just wire it like a V8 using the old key and push bottom
Start from the old V8 under the dash.

Kurt in NJ 02-05-2012 10:39 PM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

1 Attachment(s)
I have a starter on my Smiths compresser that was converted for "key" start by removing the original starter switch and soldering a short wire to the starter contact that has an eyelet terminal to a later solenoid -the solenoid was then screwed to the starter, the original battery wire would fit-the nice kind with a little button to operate it without power to make working under the hood easy ---or the threaded stud for a V8 starter could be installed

Jordan 02-05-2012 11:25 PM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

I'm pretty sure the parts suppliers sell a kit for this. not certain, but would look there first.

mrtexas 02-05-2012 11:32 PM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

I've done it. I wired from the solenoid to the starter button to the non-popout ignition switch. You wire the battery to the solenoid. I turn the ignition switch to on and hit the starter button to run the starter.

http://i371.photobucket.com/albums/o...r/Solenoid.jpg

Jim Parker Toronto 02-05-2012 11:40 PM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

I took my starter to the local shop to get the post fixed for the solenoid setup and the guy wanted $100 to do that and change to 12 volt. A little pricey I thought, so I took a couple of his business cards and left. When I got home and thought about it, I took his business cards, folded them, and stuffed them under the spring on the contact, in the box on top of the starter. This provided the necessary electrical change for the starter. I used the $100 to purchase a barrel Bendix, and a few other things. Works like a charm, and if I ever want to go back, just remove the cards and its done!

Tom Wesenberg 02-06-2012 12:20 AM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

There are other options that might be easier. You could buy the accessory upstart that fastens to the steering column, or you could use the cable pull 1932 starter.

CarlG 02-06-2012 01:42 AM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jim Parker Toronto (Post 357972)
I took my starter to the local shop to get the post fixed for the solenoid setup and the guy wanted $100 to do that and change to 12 volt. A little pricey I thought, so I took a couple of his business cards and left. When I got home and thought about it, I took his business cards, folded them, and stuffed them under the spring on the contact, in the box on top of the starter. This provided the necessary electrical change for the starter. I used the $100 to purchase a barrel Bendix, and a few other things. Works like a charm, and if I ever want to go back, just remove the cards and its done!

Way back in the dark ages, I "fixed" my starter by taking the switch off and just turning the contact strip upside down so that it was in contact at all times. That, too, worked like a charm.

Now, has anyone been able to come up with a key switch (with start) that will fit in the original dash panel?

George Miller 02-06-2012 09:39 AM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by CarlG (Post 358009)
Way back in the dark ages, I "fixed" my starter by taking the switch off and just turning the contact strip upside down so that it was in contact at all times. That, too, worked like a charm.

Now, has anyone been able to come up with a key switch (with start) that will fit in the original dash panel?

Yes but you have to use a later solenoid that takes power from the switch. The old ones work by grounding them. You need one from a 12 volt ford they come with 4 terminals instead of 3. The extra one is for 12 volts to the coil for starting.

Jim Brierley 02-06-2012 11:34 AM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

The 33-34 Model B starters were made for a remote switch, but they are hard to find. In the old days someone made a replacement switch that was for this, you see them sometimes at swap meets, if you know what to look for. I merely soldered a brass bolt onto the A "button" and it worked fine. The above solutions work too.

400A-64 02-06-2012 01:31 PM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

Be very careful of using a modern key start!!!! A friend used one and lost his car in the resulting FIRE !!After a short time the pressure against the tank and switch will puncture the boot and short out....If you must use a key start....mount the instrument panel to a spacer of your own design in order to creat a gap between switch boot and the gas tank.
Bruce Davis [email protected]

1931 flamingo 02-06-2012 06:31 PM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

To avoid what 400A-64 describes you could mount new sw assy to left of steering column on a home made brkt. JMO
Paul in CT

CarlG 02-06-2012 06:53 PM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

With this much interest in a key start switch, I would think that someone would have found or produced a shallow enough switch that could be mounted in the panel. I know that NewRex makes one that has an ACC post on it that looks like a Pop Out, that is shallow enough, but I haven't seen anything with a "start" feature that fits the bill.

All the suggestions to mount it somewhere else would work, it's just not the effect I (and others) want.

reece 02-06-2012 07:06 PM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by George Miller (Post 358093)
Yes but you have to use a later solenoid that takes power from the switch. The old ones work by grounding them. You need one from a 12 volt ford they come with 4 terminals instead of 3. The extra one is for 12 volts to the coil for starting.

You are correct with this but there is a workaround for folks who want to keep the dash button and old style solenoid.

I have wired a few cars for customers who wanted to retain the starter button on the dash (later 30s Fords and a couple of 40 Fords). To do that I mounted a 12 v relay under the dash and used the dash button to fire the relay and ground the old style solenoid on the firewall.

Logan 02-06-2012 07:07 PM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

I understand the desire for a key start, but why not just buy one of the push button starters from the suppliers? it puts a solenoid on the original starter, and then you put the button up by the steering wheel somewhere. Its a very simple set up, and it takes away the foot starter.

eagle 02-06-2012 09:19 PM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

"I understand the desire for a key start, but why not just buy one of the push..." Why would you want a key start? I haven't found any reason to not think my foot started is perfectly "cool". As long as the ebrake works for hill starting, I can't think why you would want a keystart... what am I missing?

Logan 02-06-2012 09:33 PM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by eagle (Post 358626)
"I understand the desire for a key start, but why not just buy one of the push..." Why would you want a key start? I haven't found any reason to not think my foot started is perfectly "cool". As long as the ebrake works for hill starting, I can't think why you would want a keystart... what am I missing?

for universal use. If someone has to start the car and move it, that doesnt really know anything about a model a they wont always remember where the foot starter button is. I know one older guy in our club has one, because he had troubles putting his big foot up by the brake pedals and the a/c, and his ankle didn't want to twist anymore.

Dave in Denver 02-06-2012 11:00 PM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

My reason for asking about converting to a key or push button starting rather than the stock foot starting on top of the starter is one thta comes from a bt of annoyance. I am having issues with my starter getting "stuck". What mean by stuck in the copper plate in the item on top of the starter gets "welded" to the copper button on the starter. I am getting good a taking the foot rod assembly off the top of the starter to undo the two pieces. In the past a notch has been takne out the button on the starter and I first tried filing it down to make the crevis shallower but it still likes to swallow or "weld" the copper plate to intothis crevis every once in a while when starting. I am now in the process of removing the starter to take it apart to replace the button with one that is perfectly flat with no crevis. As I was draining the water from the radiator to remove the side engine water neck to remove the starter, I had a thought about a selonoid driven starting process and wrote the question possing this thought to the board. I know I should just do it right and rebuild the starter the proper way, but too muc time in a cold garage gets a guy to thinking. I truly appreciate all the comments and discussion so far.

Dave

CarlG 02-07-2012 01:05 AM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jordan (Post 357965)
I'm pretty sure the parts suppliers sell a kit for this. not certain, but would look there first.

This is from Mac's catalog:


T51111 KIT $7.00

This is a universal kit that allows you to run a modern solenoid. There is a threaded stud (3/8" x 1-3/8") instead of the traditional flat contact button, which makes it easier to attach the battery cable.
USA made.

http://macsautoparts.com/images/189/T5111_pJPG.JPG

Steve Wastler 02-07-2012 06:29 AM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

"As I was draining the water from the radiator to remove the side engine water neck to remove the starter"


Wow, that a lot of extra work for no gain, are you running an A engine? I must be missing something. There is a NOS upstart kit on eBay, why 're-invent the wheel'?

Modelakid31 02-07-2012 08:49 AM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Logan (Post 358634)
for universal use. If someone has to start the car and move it, that doesnt really know anything about a model a they wont always remember where the foot starter button is. I know one older guy in our club has one, because he had troubles putting his big foot up by the brake pedals and the a/c, and his ankle didn't want to twist anymore.

If he didn't have a/c in the car he wouldnt have the problem. ;)

George Miller 02-07-2012 08:55 AM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave in Denver (Post 358679)
My reason for asking about converting to a key or push button starting rather than the stock foot starting on top of the starter is one thta comes from a bt of annoyance. I am having issues with my starter getting "stuck". What mean by stuck in the copper plate in the item on top of the starter gets "welded" to the copper button on the starter. I am getting good a taking the foot rod assembly off the top of the starter to undo the two pieces. In the past a notch has been takne out the button on the starter and I first tried filing it down to make the crevis shallower but it still likes to swallow or "weld" the copper plate to intothis crevis every once in a while when starting. I am now in the process of removing the starter to take it apart to replace the button with one that is perfectly flat with no crevis. As I was draining the water from the radiator to remove the side engine water neck to remove the starter, I had a thought about a selonoid driven starting process and wrote the question possing this thought to the board. I know I should just do it right and rebuild the starter the proper way, but too muc time in a cold garage gets a guy to thinking. I truly appreciate all the comments and discussion so far.

Dave

Dave see if you can find a original starter switch, that would end your problem. The repo switches that I have seen have a weak spring.

eagle 02-07-2012 09:07 AM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

I didn't mean to be critical at all. I was merely asking because I wanted to Know why you would want a keyswitch. The foot start is one of the things that the kids LOVE about riding in an A and it is sooo simple, I just never thought of a reason for changing it. I have a '52 Chev pickup that the previous owner converted to key start and I wish he hadn't. I'm going to convert it back some day.... I am 6' 4" and had to move the seat back in my A. It was dangerous to drive. Some people see that as a travesty, but it is MY A. So, whatever you want to do with YOUR A, it is your business and I don't agree with people being critical. Its not as if someone, some day, can't convert it back when its THEIR A. It does make me sick when I see an A destroyed that cannot be "converted back someday". There again, that is THEIR A, not mine.

1931 flamingo 02-07-2012 09:39 AM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

Replace your starter sw either with a reproduction or a GOOD used original. Unless you're doing something besides the starter WHY are you removing the side engine water neck?? Remove dipstick, 3 starter bolts, starter sw and the starter "sneaks" out. Just did it y/day.
Paul in CT

Dave in Denver 02-07-2012 01:32 PM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

All is good. My Engineering background always causes me to ask questions. I appreciate all the comments and suggestions. I believe I will follow the path suggested by a few and dig into my basement of spare parts to look for an original starter top.

Logan 02-07-2012 02:02 PM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Modelakid31 (Post 358854)
If he didn't have a/c in the car he wouldnt have the problem. ;)

texas is pretty hot for an 80 year old, that has had tripple bypass surgery and 4 strokes, to drive a car all summer. So yeah an ac was necessary for him to stay in the car.

Jordan 02-07-2012 02:58 PM

Re: Converting Model A to key starting
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Modelakid31 (Post 358854)
If he didn't have a/c in the car he wouldnt have the problem. ;)

MA is a lot cooler in the summer than TX


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:03 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.