The Ford Barn

The Ford Barn (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/index.php)
-   Early V8 (1932-53) (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   40 gas tank? (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/showthread.php?t=350133)

busmania 06-22-2025 08:59 AM

40 gas tank?
 

I have a drake (or carpenter, not sure but they are probably the same?) tank. It appears to be leaking pretty good where the neck attaches to the tank. This thing is basically new so I’m annoyed. Who makes a good tank? Anyone else have this leaking problem with their aftermarket tank?

19Fordy 06-22-2025 11:28 AM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

If you have a MIG or TIG welder try welding it yourself.
https://metalfixes.com/how-to-weld-a-gas-tank/

OR

Send the tank to the vendor back and get a new one.
A Fordbarn SEARCH reveals this:
https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/searc...2&pp=25&page=2

I don't think the repro tanks are made to fit the OEM 40 Ford gas tank sending unit.

Kube 06-22-2025 11:34 AM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Are you 100% certain the tank is leaking?
The design of these tanks made for common leaks at the filler tube rubber hose connection.
This is especially true if the tank was filled up all the way.

Before you remove the tank, do yourself a favor and track that leak down with certainty.

When I install a tank, I coat the rubber hose with Indian Head Shellac as directed on the bottle. Then I use modern clamps for a few days only replacing them with authentic clamps once the shellac has cured.

19Fordy 06-22-2025 12:21 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

"Kube's idea" is excellent. Perhaps it's just a "clamp leak". Double check to make sure.

glennpm 06-22-2025 12:23 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

With a repro tank you may not be concerned about using the original clamps. If the the leak is from the hose, most likely, then use two quality modern clamps spaced about 1/2" or so apart.

Glenn

busmania 06-22-2025 01:39 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

I figured it was the rubber hose from the filler tube to the tank as it was rubbing the inner fender metal so I also cut that back. So I replaced the rubber. It still leaked. So then I figured I screwed up the clamps. Nope, still leaks and here I am. I have already pulled the tank. It was easy because my trunk floor has been cut out. I plan to pressurize the tank and then spray the area I think it is with soapy water. Much like finding a hole in a tire. We will see. It almost looks like the neck wasn’t welded where it meets the tank behind a small strengthening piece of metal.

Oh, and after all this, the entire area around the filler neck rubber is dry so I do not think it’s coming from the hose part of it.

19Fordy 06-22-2025 05:30 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Can you post a few photos of the tank and where its leaking?

fordyford 06-22-2025 06:54 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

19Fordy, welding on a gas tank that has had fuel in it is dangerous, Don't do it.

busmania 06-22-2025 08:48 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

3 Attachment(s)
Welp, I pressurized the tank and as suspected it seems to be coming from behind this support piece and under the filler neck. Not sure how I’d fix this….

Hard to see but you can see a couple giant bubbles forming in these photos. Next I’ll fill it with water and see if I can see for sure where it is leaking.

Attachment 568619

Attachment 568620

Attachment 568621

petehoovie 06-22-2025 09:13 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by busmania (Post 2396367)
Welp, I pressurized the tank and as suspected it seems to be coming from behind this support piece and under the filler neck. Not sure how I’d fix this….

Hard to see but you can see a couple giant bubbles forming in these photos. Next I’ll fill it with water and see if I can see for sure where it is leaking.

Attachment 568619

Attachment 568620

Attachment 568621

https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/attac...9&d=1750643303

https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/attac...0&d=1750643303

https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/attac...1&d=1750643303

Newc 06-22-2025 11:18 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

That a 'Tanks' product? Drake mentions that area about his tanks, but 'tanks' have larger capacity. Newc

deuce lover 06-23-2025 02:56 AM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

1 Attachment(s)
Appears to be a Drake tank.Here is a pic of one currently listed on Ebay

19Fordy 06-23-2025 07:58 AM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by fordyford (Post 2396350)
19Fordy, welding on a gas tank that has had fuel in it is dangerous, Don't do it.

Here's how to do it.
https://weldingtroop.com/is-it-safe-...d-a-fuel-tank/

busmania 06-23-2025 09:57 AM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

It is either Drake or Dennis Carpenter. I do not remember and will have to go back and look at the receipts. Does anyone know if they are the same Tank? Pictures on the websites sure make them look the same.

Newc 06-23-2025 10:23 AM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Check capacity- different I think? newc

petehoovie 06-23-2025 10:25 AM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by deuce lover (Post 2396395)
Appears to be a Drake tank.Here is a pic of one currently listed on Ebay

https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/attac...5&d=1750665357

Kube 06-23-2025 10:29 AM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Man, oh man, this sucks.
I believe I would strongly consider cleaning this tank out thoroughly and applying a very good grade of sealer.

I always thought Drake's advertising was amusing. On one line it states they are "exactly as original" but then goes on to state they have a larger capacity than original and don't accept the authentic sending unit.
You know, exact only different.
I have had to use his tanks a few times and have been overall pleased. They are wider than the original as well. Oh yeah, "exact as original" only wider.
I have heard from numerous folks that they are nearly impossible to install w/o lifting the rear body or cutting the tank (flanges) shorter.

busmania 06-23-2025 05:59 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Just looked. It was Dennis carpenter. I wonder if the drake tank is the same manufacture? I do t want to buy and have the same issues!

deuce lover 06-24-2025 06:06 AM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

In 2007 I replaced a rotten fuel tank in a 35 slantback tudor.I had no issues whatsoever with installing it.No lifting the body and it slipped in the chassis easily. I did this again in 2011 in a 36 5W and again no issues.Both were Drake tanks.I didn't care for the battleship gray color and paint them both black .

V8 Bob 06-24-2025 07:11 AM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

I prefer SS for a fuel tank, and had Rock Valley custom build the tanks in my '32 and '40. Not cheap, but NO issues.

busmania 06-24-2025 09:39 AM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

This morning i woke up and wanted to drive my car but couldn’t (apparently these things need a gas tank to drive more than 25 ft). So, i bought the drake tank. Hoping it’s a different manufacturer than Dennis carpenter. Didn’t want the oversized fuel tanks from tank inc so not many options it seems. We will see.

Kube 06-24-2025 01:29 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by busmania (Post 2396677)
This morning i woke up and wanted to drive my car but couldn’t (apparently these things need a gas tank to drive more than 25 ft). So, i bought the drake tank. Hoping it’s a different manufacturer than Dennis carpenter. Didn’t want the oversized fuel tanks from tank inc so not many options it seems. We will see.

I have installed a number of Drakes tanks. I'm fairly certain that is what Carpenter sells as well.
Unless Drake improved (read: corrected) his design, you will find the tank a bit too wide to install easily. I'd never had an issue as the bodies were always off while I restored the chassis.
The Drake tanks do have a larger capacity than the original.

busmania 06-24-2025 02:00 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

The good news is my trunk is cut out currently so removing and re installing is a breeze. Haha. I probably just got a “bad” one. Sucks buying parts 3 years in advanced (I had the money then) only to find out after the fact it’s bad and now it’s been too long to file a complaint with the I (Dennis carpenter) don’t actually care department. I do find it strange it was fine for the first year of use (1500 miles) and then just all the sudden shit the bed. I’m not actually convinced my tank is bad yet but the bubbles don’t really lie.

Kube 06-24-2025 02:04 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by busmania (Post 2396742)
The good news is my trunk is cut out currently so removing and re installing is a breeze. Haha. I probably just got a “bad” one. Sucks buying parts 3 years in advanced (I had the money then) only to find out after the fact it’s bad and now it’s been too long to file a complaint with the I (Dennis carpenter) don’t actually care department. I do find it strange it was fine for the first year of use (1500 miles) and then just all the sudden shit the bed. I’m not actually convinced my tank is bad yet but the bubbles don’t really lie.

I'm willing to bet a good coating of sealer would make that tank usable.

busmania 06-24-2025 02:37 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

2 Attachment(s)
I have no doubt you are right kube. I just don’t have time for that at the moment.

I just tested the old tank again and now I’m confident it’s leaking under the filler neck where that reinforced piece of metal is.

Edit
Did a 3rd test. Filled it with water, then plugged all the holes and pressurized it ever so slightly with some air. As suspected, water shooting out under the filler neck like a fire hose. Hard to see in photos but now I’m certain this tank is bad. I love aftermarket parts!

Attachment 568751

Attachment 568752

busmania 06-26-2025 08:20 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

4 Attachment(s)
Updating this for future readers. I got the drake tank. They are very similar but ever so different so I’m hoping it’s a different manufacturer. The drake tank has a drake logo embossed on it. Also the corners are slightly different. The photos make the drake tank look bigger but it’s not. Same size and almost identical shape.

Attachment 568864

Attachment 568865

Attachment 568866

Attachment 568867

petehoovie 06-26-2025 09:00 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by busmania (Post 2397159)
Updating this for future readers. I got the drake tank. They are very similar but ever so different so I’m hoping it’s a different manufacturer. The drake tank has a drake logo embossed on it. Also the corners are slightly different. The photos make the drake tank look bigger but it’s not. Same size and almost identical shape.

https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/attac...4&d=1750987201

https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/attac...5&d=1750987201

https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/attac...6&d=1750987201

https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/attac...7&d=1750987201

deuce_roadster 06-27-2025 10:28 AM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

My 40 V8 (standard) coupe came to me with truckloads of NOS parts as the previous owner bought the car in 1957 and at that time bought everything he could find from dealerships. I had 2 NOS gas tanks and when I took the old one out it was a bit of a war and installing the NOS one was just as difficult. I would bet a lot of money the tank was installed before the body on the assembly line. Never any damage on this car, 47k miles and still had original waffle tar paper in the tool area. The only car I have ever had that had NO rust and NO dents after taking the body down to bare metal before repainting it CMG. 40 tanks can be a pain unless the body is off.

deuce_roadster 06-27-2025 10:33 AM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Accidental duplicate.

Bob Drake Repro 07-01-2025 10:32 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Hi All. We have had a lot of questions on our tanks over the years, so we made a quick video highlighting the differences between the Drake-Tank and the competitor's tank. The video is a little dry (it was made by our R&D team), but highlights the major differences. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6SXkNkjxojI

19Fordy 07-02-2025 08:24 AM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Excellent video. Thanks for posting it.
Can't help but wonder who makes the "competitor tank"?




Quote:

Originally Posted by Bob Drake Repro (Post 2398178)
Hi All. We have had a lot of questions on our tanks over the years, so we made a quick video highlighting the differences between the Drake-Tank and the competitor's tank. The video is a little dry (it was made by our R&D team), but highlights the major differences. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6SXkNkjxojI


2dasand 07-02-2025 09:55 AM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Why is everyone against the larger Tanks unit?

Fritz 07-02-2025 04:26 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Not sure if anyone is really against the Tanks Inc unit, but it is not "as original." It works and fits, I have one, but it would not pass a concourse judging. The Tanks Inc unit is not the competitor tank in the video. Tanks Inc doesn't put a drain on their tank or the side bracing.

busmania 07-02-2025 07:25 PM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by 2dasand (Post 2398257)
Why is everyone against the larger Tanks unit?

I’m not against it but have no need for it. I dont drive long distances so then add in the fact it looks “different” means I dont want it. Also I was told it hangs down lower and is visibly different from the back. My car is lowered so I don’t need the tank scraping the pavement. I have enough problems as it is.

deuce_roadster 07-03-2025 09:16 AM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

Like I posted, I had enough trouble installing a NOS 40 Ford gas tank in a never damaged car, I can't imagine the fight would be for one that was larger, unless the body was already off.
Getting the original out was just as difficult.

19Fordy 07-03-2025 09:54 AM

Re: 40 gas tank?
 

5 Attachment(s)
I guess I was lucky. Both my stock OEM 40 tank and my TANKS larger polyethylene tank were installed in my 40 coupe without having to lift body up off frame. Also added a drain plug to the TANKS tank.

The problems with the TANKS tank was that I had to enlarge the hole to allow the stock sending unit to slide in AND also make new mounting screw holes using Nutserts as the TANKS tank does not have the OEM gas tank sending unit screw holes. I don't know if this is true for their metal tanks. Plus, the TANKS plastic tank does not have cage nuts to secure it in place. I had to use toggle bolts. Finally, the TANKS plastic tank does not use gravity feed like the OEM so you have to reroute your fuel line.

Given these "problems" I would recommend using an original tank or the aftermarket tank that installs easily and is just like the OEM tank.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:14 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.