Go Back   The Ford Barn > General Discussion > Model A (1928-31)

Sponsored Links (Register now to hide all advertisements)

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 02-07-2016, 07:19 PM   #1
J Witt
Senior Member
 
J Witt's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2015
Location: Acworth GA
Posts: 534
Default intermittent dead starter

I'm having an intermittent problem with the starter acting like it has no electrical power. I can jumper direct to the copper pass through and it still won't run, but most of the time it will turn the engine over nicely. So far it hasn't stranded me, but I know my luck will run out. Probably in front of an admiring crowd.

My thought is that there is an open winding that periodically ends up under the brushes, but I figure the forum will have some suggestions. I may take it off the car tomorrow for a closer look.

The battery is currently at 6.8V and the solenoid is closing with a solid click. All the connections between battery and starter are showing good voltage, but the starter is not pulling the battery down at all, so no current is passing through it.

Thanks,

John
__________________
Houston, Tranquility base here. The Eagle has landed.
J Witt is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-07-2016, 08:22 PM   #2
hardtimes
Senior Member
 
hardtimes's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: South California
Posts: 6,188
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

Quote:
Originally Posted by J Witt View Post
I'm having an intermittent problem with the starter acting like it has no electrical power. I can jumper direct to the copper pass through and it still won't run, but most of the time it will turn the engine over nicely. So far it hasn't stranded me, but I know my luck will run out. Probably in front of an admiring crowd.

My thought is that there is an open winding that periodically ends up under the brushes, but I figure the forum will have some suggestions. I may take it off the car tomorrow for a closer look.

The battery is currently at 6.8V and the solenoid is closing with a solid click. All the connections between battery and starter are showing good voltage, but the starter is not pulling the battery down at all, so no current is passing through it.

Thanks,

John
Hey John,
Two things come to mind with your symptoms.
First , I'd check the easiest first...starter switch contacts function.
Then , I'd pull the starter and look over the segmented copper (commutator) that the brushes ride on. A FLAT spot will act exactly as you describe. Next time that it happens, bump the starter several quick times to see whether that will bump it past the flat spot. Maybe needs a rebuild ?

Last edited by hardtimes; 02-08-2016 at 06:03 PM. Reason: .....
hardtimes is offline   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links (Register now to hide all advertisements)
Old 02-07-2016, 08:42 PM   #3
Y-Blockhead
Senior Member
 
Y-Blockhead's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: Redondo Beach, CA
Posts: 5,817
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

My first thought is the commutator.

Solenoid???

Last edited by Y-Blockhead; 02-07-2016 at 08:51 PM.
Y-Blockhead is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-07-2016, 08:52 PM   #4
mike657894
Senior Member
 
mike657894's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2015
Location: Bay City Michigan
Posts: 1,050
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

tighten battery terminals tighten contacts
mike657894 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-07-2016, 08:57 PM   #5
J Witt
Senior Member
 
J Witt's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2015
Location: Acworth GA
Posts: 534
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

As I said, I've been through all the connections. A new piece of data though, it will crank over well with the battery freshly charged to about 7 volts. I think I'll take the battery over to the LAS and get it load tested.

With my ordinary run of luck, it will be the starter AND the battery.

John
__________________
Houston, Tranquility base here. The Eagle has landed.
J Witt is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-07-2016, 10:33 PM   #6
Jerry in Shasta
Senior Member
 
Jerry in Shasta's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: (Old)Shasta (Redding) CA
Posts: 385
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

Sponsored Links (Register now to hide all advertisements)
When the starter won't turn try tapping on it with a hammer. Sounds like a hanging brush or a out of round commutator.

Chev. had this same problem a few years ago.

JB
__________________
Connoisseur of Rust
Jerry in Shasta is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-07-2016, 11:48 PM   #7
Chuck Sea/Tac
Senior Member
 
Chuck Sea/Tac's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: Between Seattle & Tacoma
Posts: 2,351
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

What solenoid??
Chuck Sea/Tac is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-08-2016, 07:14 AM   #8
Jwilli
Senior Member
 
Jwilli's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: Kennesaw, Ga
Posts: 511
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

John, there is a shop in Marietta that I have been using for over 50 years. They still know how to work on antiques. Call me if you need their address. Jim
Jwilli is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-08-2016, 07:36 AM   #9
Patrick L.
Senior Member
 
Patrick L.'s Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: Largo Florida
Posts: 7,225
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

If the starter switch contacts have been cleaned and are good, then I'd suspect the armature/commutator. The commutator can be checked with a VOM and the armature with a growler for opens. It appears there could be a dead spot in one or both.
Patrick L. is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-08-2016, 07:48 AM   #10
J Witt
Senior Member
 
J Witt's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2015
Location: Acworth GA
Posts: 534
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

Thanks for the advice. I'll get to spend some more time on it later this week and will keep you posted on what I find.

I agree, it's likely to be a dead spot on the commutator/armature. There's a local auto electric shop that still does old car work, so I may head over there and let a pro test it. It's part of the fun for me to figure these things out and fix them myself if possible.

John
__________________
Houston, Tranquility base here. The Eagle has landed.
J Witt is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-08-2016, 11:36 AM   #11
Tom Wesenberg
Senior Member
 
Tom Wesenberg's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: Mpls, MN
Posts: 27,582
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

Your brushes might be worn out. I usually find the two ground brushes wear out about twice as fast as the two field brushes. The ground brushes are easily changed by just removing the 2 screws and installing the new brushes.

If the 2 field brushes also need to be changed then you need a good size soldering gun, such as a WEN 250, or a large soldering iron.

Take a picture or make a drawing of where the 4 brushes fit, to be sure they go back in the correct location. Do not undercut the commutator if you have to clean it up.
Tom Wesenberg is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-08-2016, 11:39 AM   #12
katy
Senior Member
 
katy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2015
Location: Red Deer, Alberta
Posts: 5,011
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

Admit it, the starter need to be removed and repaired. Don't fudge about, just do it.
__________________
If you don't hear a rumor by 10 AM, start one!.
Got my education out behind the barn!
katy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-08-2016, 04:48 PM   #13
J Witt
Senior Member
 
J Witt's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2015
Location: Acworth GA
Posts: 534
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

Come on now, procrastination is the key to flexibility. Besides, I'm gonna leave Bourbon and cookies out tonight for the wrench elves.

Tom, why do you say not to undercut the commutator?
__________________
Houston, Tranquility base here. The Eagle has landed.
J Witt is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-08-2016, 05:06 PM   #14
Patrick L.
Senior Member
 
Patrick L.'s Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: Largo Florida
Posts: 7,225
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

Quote:
Originally Posted by J Witt View Post
Come on now, procrastination is the key to flexibility. Besides, I'm gonna leave Bourbon and cookies out tonight for the wrench elves.

Tom, why do you say not to undercut the commutator?


He is talking about the mica between the commutator sections. A starter runs in short bursts not requiring the cutting like is done to the generator.
Patrick L. is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-08-2016, 06:01 PM   #15
hardtimes
Senior Member
 
hardtimes's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: South California
Posts: 6,188
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tom Wesenberg View Post
Your brushes might be worn out. I usually find the two ground brushes wear out about twice as fast as the two field brushes. The ground brushes are easily changed by just removing the 2 screws and installing the new brushes.

If the 2 field brushes also need to be changed then you need a good size soldering gun, such as a WEN 250, or a large soldering iron.

Take a picture or make a drawing of where the 4 brushes fit, to be sure they go back in the correct location. Do not undercut the commutator if you have to clean it up.
Hey Tom,
For many decades, I have 'undercut the mica' on both gen and starter commutators. Then finish by polishing a little. Never have heard that statement...'do not'. Matter of fact, a machine/device was commercially made to do the undercut
hardtimes is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-08-2016, 07:48 PM   #16
Tom Wesenberg
Senior Member
 
Tom Wesenberg's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: Mpls, MN
Posts: 27,582
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

Quote:
Originally Posted by J Witt View Post
Come on now, procrastination is the key to flexibility. Besides, I'm gonna leave Bourbon and cookies out tonight for the wrench elves.

Tom, why do you say not to undercut the commutator?
Because of the strong springs and metal brushes, the mica wears as the commutator wears, so it doesn't need to be undercut. I worked on a starter where someone had undercut the commutator, and some metal from the brushes and commutator had actually shorted the bars.

Generators have carbon brushes and weaker springs, so they get undercut about .010" or a hair more, otherwise the brushes can ride over the insulators and arc on the bars.
Tom Wesenberg is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-09-2016, 09:06 AM   #17
Jacksonlll
Senior Member
 
Jacksonlll's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Michigan-- Member of Oakleaf of MARC
Posts: 1,686
Send a message via ICQ to Jacksonlll
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

I know you checked the batt connections, but you better do a good job of it. Every connection. It can show good voltage with no load, but it can't pass the high current through. Also look at the connection of the batt cable to the terminal that fastens to the batt posts. If that crimp is rusty or loose, it can drive you crazy. You must have a good, tight crimp around the cable wires. I had to drive a nail in one to get good contact.
Jacksonlll is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-09-2016, 01:39 PM   #18
J Witt
Senior Member
 
J Witt's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2015
Location: Acworth GA
Posts: 534
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

Tom, that's very interesting, hadn't heard about that feature, but that does make sense.

I have the starter in the hands of a rebuild shop right now and will let everyone know what transpires (Friday probably). This shop supposedly has a lot of expertise on both A and T starters and generators.

As far as checking the connections, I removed the starter contactor and jumpered directly to the starter connections with no resulting rotation of the starter. That removes all the intermediate connections. It is fairly obvious to check through all the connections to look for the open/loose one, including to check the frame/engine ground and battery ground to frame.

On the other hand when the starter had it in its mind to run, it would start the engine repeatedly. The auto electric gentleman was of the opinion (without having it apart yet) that the problem was likely a bad winding or commutator segment in the armature.

Thanks to all for the helpful comments,

John
__________________
Houston, Tranquility base here. The Eagle has landed.
J Witt is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-09-2016, 03:02 PM   #19
H. L. Chauvin
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 4,179
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

Just one opinion from quite a few vintage past experiences:

The minute an 80+ year old properly "grounded" starter begins to drag or slow down while using a fully "charged" good battery, with all "clean" electrical connections, and a fully "operable" starter switch, it is always best to immediately further investigate the starter and not wait like that of many vehicle operators.

Slow turning "worn" starters begin to generate intensive heat which rapidly wears metal parts ...... they always get worse as time goes on ...... never better.

As starters continue to get hotter, (sometimes smoking), one day the starter will wear enough to die ...... hence, after far more damage is done.

Most common are commutator cylindrical level surfaces get worn down unevenly with worn uneven brushes, commutators get out of round, hard steel brush holders can later wear soft metal commutators in a jiffy.

On old vintage starters with unknown history:

1. Replacing old starter bushings with new greased starter bushings for under $5.00 is a steal.

2. Replacing starter brushes on old starters at under $5.00, once starters are dismantled can never hurt.

3. One can test for armature commutator continuity between commutator segments with a test lamp and repair old field coil tape with electrical tape.

4. With armature shaft set in (2) simple wood shaped vertical 1 x 4 vees, armature can be rotated by hand .... a flat mill file can be set up on level wood shims to correct an out-of-round and/or un-level worn soft metal commutator, followed by polishing commutator with fine sand paper.

5. Not much to it for a Model A handyman willing to try .... and ....... after careful completion .... your simple, starter re-build procedure can be as good as making a one (1) time $10.00 payment on a 50 year Life Insurance Policy.

Hope this helps.

Last edited by H. L. Chauvin; 02-09-2016 at 03:06 PM. Reason: typo
H. L. Chauvin is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-09-2016, 09:21 PM   #20
Super Piasan
Junior Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2014
Location: Cedar Rapids, IA
Posts: 3
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

Check the commutator is clean and the brushes are still good. Weak brush springs or a broken brush spring, or a brush hanging up in the brush holder will cause this problem. Also, check the commutator end bushing and the drive end bushing. Could be the armature is rubbing on the field pole shoes too.
Super Piasan is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-10-2016, 02:53 PM   #21
mshmodela
Senior Member
 
mshmodela's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: Cleveland, Ohio
Posts: 2,763
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

Quote:
Originally Posted by J Witt View Post
I'm having an intermittent problem with the starter acting like it has no electrical power. I can jumper direct to the copper pass through and it still won't run, but most of the time it will turn the engine over nicely. So far it hasn't stranded me, but I know my luck will run out. Probably in front of an admiring crowd.

My thought is that there is an open winding that periodically ends up under the brushes, but I figure the forum will have some suggestions. I may take it off the car tomorrow for a closer look.

The battery is currently at 6.8V and the solenoid is closing with a solid click. All the connections between battery and starter are showing good voltage, but the starter is not pulling the battery down at all, so no current is passing through it.

Thanks,

John

My guess is your battery is weak... I'd put a charger on it for 12 hrs and see if that makes a difference... (My Battery became weak on a 2A trickle charger...) It was only after 2, 12hour charging sessions @ 6A did she have enough current to spin the engine... Thus far 4 months and no re-charging... and she held a charge without being started for 3 and half weeks..)

Anyway something simple to try...
__________________
-Mike

Late 31' Ford Model A Tudor, Miss Daisy

I don't work on cars --I'm learning about my Model A.

Cleveland, Ohio
mshmodela is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-11-2016, 06:35 PM   #22
hale1776
Senior Member
 
hale1776's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: Connecticut
Posts: 130
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

Sometimes bendix hangs on ring gear locking everything up. Putting it in third and rocking car, you will hear it when it pops back. Same symptoms. engage starter nothing all electrical check out fine. There is a reason this happens but I forgot it. Good luck.
hale1776 is offline   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links (Register now to hide all advertisements)
Old 02-13-2016, 08:16 AM   #23
J Witt
Senior Member
 
J Witt's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2015
Location: Acworth GA
Posts: 534
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

The overhauled starter is back on the car and the rework made a huge difference in how fast the engine turns over. I'd guess maybe twice as fast as before.

The repair guy said there were several dead commutator segments where the windings had come unsoldered, plus commutator out of round, worn brushes, etc. He resoldered the loose windings, refinished the commutator, new bushings, new brushes, everything cleaned up and the result is like new performance. Who'da thunk it!

For those in the Atlanta area: Auto Electric Remanufacturing. Nice work, very reasonable price.

Thanks to all for your comments and guesses,

John
__________________
Houston, Tranquility base here. The Eagle has landed.
J Witt is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-13-2016, 09:08 AM   #24
C26Pinelake
BANNED
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: Michigan / Ontario border, Sarnia, Ontario. 50 miles from Detroit and 150 from Toronto.
Posts: 5,800
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

Did you remove the starter yet? Obviously it has gone removed! Talk isnt going to fix it. Wayne
C26Pinelake is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-13-2016, 09:45 AM   #25
Jwilli
Senior Member
 
Jwilli's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: Kennesaw, Ga
Posts: 511
Default Re: intermittent dead starter

Glad it worked for you. I have had good results with them for many years.
Jwilli is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Sponsored Links (Register now to hide all advertisements)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:23 AM.